A grammar of an elvish language from jrr tolkiens lord of the rings by david salo at indigo. A grammar of an elvish language from jrr tolkiens lord of the rings david salo. Compare cheapest textbook prices for a gateway to sindarin. Buy a discounted paperback of a gateway to sindarin online from australias leading online bookstore. Within explore neo sindarin academics, learn simple linguistic concepts, practice useful phrases while studying grammar, and look at the world through elven eyes. Though only part of his work on his languages has been published, salo believes enough is. I was expecting and hoping for a text in the same vein as wheelocks latin, perhaps, but for sindarin which i see now was foolish of me, but what ive found is a very dense tome that i would most kindly describe as. Rather, it is an unacknowledged mishmash of noldorin of the 1930s from the etymologies, sindarin of the 1950s from the lord of the rings, and numerous inventions of david salo himself. Through no fault of its own, the book is handicapped in that it attempts to generate a clear snapshot of an elusive entity that is, in more. Tolkiens lord of the rings by david salo overview from the 1910s to the 1970s, author and linguist j. A grammar of an elvish language from jrr tolkiens lord of the rings 1st edition. The university of utah press is a member of the assosiation of american university presses. From the 1910s to the 1970s, author and linguist j. Dec 20, 2018 like his other languages, sindarin was a new invention, not based on any existing or artificial language.
I have a veritable miniature tolkien library there are only three books i dont own yet, so this is my own opinion on what adds information, whats just nice to have, and what doesnt have anything to do with sindarin or middle earth whatsoever but is useful for tolkien scholars. A grammar of an elvish language from jrr tolkiens lord of the. Tolkiens invented languages, this book is not a reliable gateway to sindarin. Through no fault of its own, the book is handicapped in that it attempts to generate a clear snapshot of an. Tolkiens lord of the rings by david salo, 9780874809121, available at book depository with free a gateway to sindarin a gateway to sindarin ebook download as pdf file.
What emerges is an homage to tolkiens scholarly philological efforts. Now david salo, probably most famous for the creation of the elvish dialogues in the lord of the rings movies has published his ideas on the grammar of sindarin. Free shipping and pickup in store on eligible orders. A grammar of an elvish language from jrr tolkiens lord of the rings. Sindarin was designed to have a welshlike phonology. Jan 24, 2020 micah rated it did not like it may 19, this book is a wonderful, indepth guide to sindarin as a contributor to the officially licensed middleearth tabletop the one ring, this is a great reference for the linguistically inclined tolkien fan. I am rather surprised that this books gets such a bad rap in the tolkienic linguistics community.
Like his other languages, sindarin was a new invention, not. This book is quite detailed to get the most out of it you would need to have linguistic expertise. Included is the most current information available to fans. In a gateway to sindarin, david salo has created a volume that is a serious look at an entertaining topic. Sindarin is one of the many languages spoken by the elves, called the eledhrim lr. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them.
Tolkien s lord of the rings by david s sindarin language. Sindarin was one of the last languages author and linguist tolkien developed, and like the others it was not intended to be ideal in any way, but to be plausibly realistic as a pretended natural language. A gateway to sindarin david salo haftad 9780874809121. Salo is a linguist who worked on the languages of j. A grammar of an elvish language from jrr tolkiens lord of the rings, david salo 9780874809121. J r r tolkien from the 1910s to the 1970s, author and linguist j. On the bow, tengwar in beleriandic mode read annon na edhellen, which is a neo sindarin translation of the book. Booktopia has a gateway to sindarin, a grammar of an elvish language from jrr tolkiens lord of the rings by david salo. A gateway to sindarin, a grammar of an elvish language from. Tolkien worked at creating plausibly realistic languages to be used by the creatures and characters in his. A gateway to sindarin pdf david salo a gateway to sindarin a grammar of an elvish language free ebook download as pdf file. Getting into even explaining the tonal aspects of how. A serious linguistic analysis of tolkiens sindarin language.
Interview with david salo tolkien elves and gateway to sindarin. Like his other languages, sindarin was a new invention, not based on any existing or artificial language. Librarything is a cataloging and social networking site for booklovers. Sindarin is one of the many languages spoken by the elves, called the eledhrim l. After you print the label, simply drop the book in the mail with the shipping label and youll have that sweet sweet cash or amazon store credit if you sold through amazon tradein. The book represents rather a grammar of sindarin as salo thinks it should be, sometimes regardless of what tolkien wrote. This book functions as a friendly introduction to the neo sindarin community. Within explore neosindarin academics, learn simple linguistic concepts, practice useful phrases while studying grammar, and look at the world through elven eyes. Salos book is not a presentation of sindarin as tolkien defined. It has most of the same sounds and similar phonotactics. Jan 01, 2020 sindarin is mainly analytic, though traits of its highly inflected progenitor can still be seen. Apr 01, 2007 in a gateway to sindarin, david salo has created a volume that is a serious look at an entertaining topic. Tolkien for use in his fantasy stories set in arda, primarily in middleearth. A gateway to sindarin by david salo, 9780874809121, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide.
Whether one calls the language thus generated negatively movieelvish or neutrally neo sindarin betrays ones attitude toward such texts. David salos a gateway to sindarin has a lot of issues. Sindarin is one of the fictional languages devised by j. Includes the grammar, morphology, and history of the language.
A gateway to sindarin, a grammar of an elvish language. Jan 28, francesco scarlata rated it really liked it. Interview with david salo tolkien elves and gateway to. A gateway to sindarin pdf beyond personal training.
I have this book and got it for a friends birthday. Im gonna sound like a noob here, but which book is the best resource for learning one or all of the different elf languages. This work is not as intellectually honest as it should be, given the amount of scholarship that has gone into the study of tolkiens invented languages. Tolkiens lord of the rings is a 2004 book by linguist david salo. In 2003, he was a graduate student in linguistics at the university. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. This ambitious and helpful book pits itself against numerous predetermined and fundamental disadvantages. Supplemental material includes a vocabulary, sindarin names, a glossary of terms, and an annotated list of works relevant to sindarin. Salo covers the grammar, morphology, and history of the language. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. On the bow, tengwar in beleriandic mode read annon na edhellen, which is a neosindarin translation of the book s title. The word sindarin is itself a quenya form, as the sindar, or grey elves themselves did not have a name for it, likely simply calling it edhellen elvish. Through no fault of its own, the book is handicapped in that it attempts to generate a clear snapshot of an elusive entity that is, in more than one way, a moving target. This book functions as a friendly introduction to the neosindarin community.
It reproduces all extant sindarin fragments from published sources both the easily available ones and the more obscure ones from linguistic journals such as vinyar tengwar and parma eldalamberon. Micah rated it did not like it may 19, this book is a wonderful, indepth guide to sindarin as a contributor to the officially licensed middleearth tabletop the one ring, this is a great reference for the linguistically inclined tolkien fan. I just today got a gateway to sindarin by david salo, a book and author im sure many of you are more or less familiar with. Tolkien for the lord of the rings film trilogy, expanding the elvish languages particularly sindarin by building on vocabulary already known from published works, and defining some languages that previously had a very small published vocabulary. Whether one calls the language thus generated negatively movieelvish or neutrally neosindarin betrays ones attitude toward such texts. Tolkien worked at creating plausibly realistic languages to be used by the creatures and characters in his novels.
843 1482 527 622 466 1525 1548 456 1346 467 1354 144 1273 492 1475 1347 206 639 751 441 76 35 202 1299 527 1246 905 1365 802 1010 23